By Dr. Avi Verma

The recent debate between President Joe Biden and former President Donald Trump was a critical event in the 2024 presidential race, marked by sharp exchanges and significant media attention. Both candidates, the oldest ever in a presidential race, showcased their distinct styles and engaged in personal attacks, each attempting to gain the upper hand.

Debate Performance
Joe Biden: Biden’s performance began shakily, characterized by a hoarse voice and occasional stumbling over his words. This fueled concerns among Democrats about his age and capacity to serve another term. Despite the rocky start, Biden found his footing midway through the debate, particularly when he targeted Trump over his conviction related to hush money payments to Stormy Daniels. Biden also highlighted the lack of endorsements for Trump from his former cabinet members, suggesting a lack of trust from those who had worked closely with him.

Donald Trump: Trump maintained a combative stance throughout the debate, launching a series of criticisms at Biden, many of which were factually dubious. He attacked Biden on various issues, including immigration, crime, and the economy, aiming to energize his base. However, his approach risked alienating moderate voters. Trump’s refusal to take responsibility for the January 6th Capitol attack and his claims about the innocence of many arrested participants stood out as particularly controversial moments.

Media Analysis and Perceptions
The media’s reaction to the debate was mixed, mirroring the deep polarization in American politics. Biden’s initial struggle and the ongoing concerns about his age were major points of discussion. His supporters, however, emphasized his administration’s achievements and his overall record, seeking to downplay
the debate’s impact on his candidacy.

Trump’s performance was noted for its assertiveness and the repetition of several debunked claims. While this approach likely reinforced support among his base, it did little to attract undecided or moderate voters. Analysts suggested that Trump’s rhetoric and his ongoing refusal to acknowledge the legitimacy of the 2020 election results might reinforce concerns about his commitment to democratic norms.

Who Won?
Determining the debate’s winner is subjective and heavily influenced by individual perspectives. Biden’s policy-focused approach and experience might appeal to voters seeking stability and detailed governance, despite his shaky start. On the other hand, Trump’s commanding presence and aggressive style could resonate with those who prioritize strong leadership, though his tendency to repeat falsehoods could undermine his appeal to undecided voters.

Should Biden Drop Out?
The debate has intensified discussions about Biden’s age and fitness for office, with some Democrats expressing concern and suggesting he might consider stepping aside. Nonetheless, there is currently no compelling reason for Biden to drop out. His administration’s achievements and substantial support within the Democratic Party provide a solid foundation for his re-election bid. Calls for him to step down would only gain traction if there were severe health issues or a dramatic shift in public support, neither of which are evident at this time.

In conclusion, the debate underscored the significant contrasts between Biden and Trump, both in style and substance. Biden’s focus on policy and experience offered a vision of steady governance, while Trump’s assertive and direct approach aimed to portray strong leadership. The ultimate outcome of the debate, and the election, will hinge on
how effectively each candidate’s message resonates with the American electorate in the coming months.